OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns and Altman returns
Newsflash: The staff of OpenAI are in open revolt over the shock departure of Sam Altman.
Around 500 staff have signed a letter threatening to leave unless the board resigns and reinstates Sam Altman as CEO, along with cofounder and former president Greg Brockman.
The letter says OpenAI (the firm behind ChatGPT) has pushed the field of artificial intelligence to new frontiers, but warns:
“The process through which you terminated Sam Altman and removed Greg Brockman from the board has jeopardized all of this work and undermined our mission and company.
Your conduct has made it clear you did not have the competence to oversee OpenAI.”
The letter has emerged just hours after Microsoft revealed it had hired Altman and Brockman, just after weekend negotiations to reinstate Altman under pressure from investers floundered.
In the letter, the staff say they may choose to resign and join Microsoft’s new AI division which will be run by Altman and Brockman.
They tell the board that the letter’s signaturies are “unable to work for or with people that lack competence, judgment and care for our mission and employees.”
Technology journalist Kara Swisher has posted the letter on X (formerly Twitter) – and points out that OpenAI’s chief scientist, Ilya Sutskever, has signed it, even though he is a member of the board that fired Altman.
As flagged earlier, Sutskever has posted on X today that “I deeply regret my participation in the board’s actions”.
That came shortly after OpenAI appointed Emmett Shear, the co-founder of Twitch, as interim CEO.
Altman had posted a photo yesterday of himself in the OpenAI offices, wearing a guest visitor badge for the “first and last time”, fuelling speculation he could be dramatically reappointed just a few days after being ousted.
Key events
Sheikh Mansour-backed, Jeff Zucker-led RedBird IMI confirms it intends to convert a loan to the Barclay family into ownership of the Telegraph and Spectator “at an early opportunity”
— Thomas Seal (@TW_Seal) November 20, 2023
Abu-Dhabi backed fund says it is set to take control of Telegraph
Newsflash: an Abu-Dhabi backed fund has said it is set to take control of the Telegraph newspaper group, after agreeing loans to repay debts owed by its previous owners, the Barclay family.
The news from RedBird IMI comes a month after the sale of the Telegraph newspapers and the Spectator kicked off.
#Breaking Abu-Dhabi backed investment fund RedBird IMI has said it is set to take control of the Telegraph and Spectator publications after agreeing loans to repay debts owed by previous owners, the Barclay family pic.twitter.com/1pHNXbmgUk
— PA Media (@PA) November 20, 2023
Lloyds Bank has been holding an auction process, after taking control of the titles from the Barclay family after a row over more than £1bn in unpaid debt.
The Barclays, though, had tabled an offer valuing the Telegraph newspaper group at £1bn in an attempt to deter rival bidders.
Yesterday, a group of Conservative MPs wrote to the government asking it to use the UK’s national security laws to investigate the Barclay family’s attempt to regain control of the Telegraph newspaper group with funding from Abu Dhabi.
A spokesman for RedBird IMI says:
“RedBird IMI, a joint venture between RedBird Capital of the US and International Media Investments of Abu Dhabi, has reached an agreement to provide a package of loans to the Barclay family allowing them to pay off their debt to Lloyds Bank in full and bring the Telegraph and Spectator out of receivership.
“RedBird IMI will provide a loan to the value of £600 million, secured against the Telegraph and Spectator.
“Additionally, International Media Investments will provide a loan of a similar amount secured against other Barclay family businesses and commercial interests.
“Under the terms of this agreement, RedBird IMI has an option to convert the loan secured against the Telegraph and Spectator into equity, and intends to exercise this option at an early opportunity.
“Any transfer of ownership will of course be subject to regulatory review and we will continue to co-operate fully with the Government and the regulator.”
The spokesman for RedBird IMI added:
“Following transfer of ownership, RedBird Capital alone will take over management and operational responsibility for the titles under the leadership of RedBird IMI chief executive Jeff Zucker.
“International Media Investments will be a passive investor only.
“RedBird IMI are entirely committed to maintaining the existing editorial team of the Telegraph and Spectator publications, and believe that editorial independence for these titles is essential to protecting their reputation and credibility.
“We are excited by the opportunity to support the titles’ existing management to expand the reach of the titles in the UK, the US and other English-speaking countries.”
JPM’s Atherton: “For MSFT, this clears one big overhang… Altman isn’t going to form a new AI venture with the wave of individuals that resigned from OpenAI following his dismissal.”
— James Pethokoukis ⏩️⤴️ (@JimPethokoukis) November 20, 2023
Evercore ISI analyst Kirk Materne has written in a note that Sam Altman’s move to Microsoft is a “clear win” for the tech giant, and “should help offset concerns regarding potential near-term uncertainty at OpenAI.”
More here.
Over on FT Alphaville, Bryce Elder has written a rather witty piece on the drama in the artificial intelligence world, titled How to talk to an elderly relative about Altman, OpenAI and Microsoft.
You can see it all here (registration needed, but worth it), arguing that you probably don’t need to care very much about the drama.
But here’s a couple of key points, which help explain the situation to anyone without a firm grip on the fast-moving world of large language AI models.
Why was Altman fired?
He was not “consistently candid in his communications”, OpenAI said, without elaborating. The general theme of reporting so far is that the board was split over Altman’s commercialisation efforts, including his tapping up SoftBank for an AI chip venture.
But also, the Temple was running low on Wizards. Three of the more commercially minded board directors resigned earlier this year — Presidential candidate Will Hurd, LinkedIn cofounder Reid Hoffman and Shivon Zilis, a VC who’s been friendly at least once with OpenAI founder investor Elon Musk — which reduced the board to six and gave doomwarts like OpenAI chief scientist Ilya Sutskever greater influence.
Things came to a head at OpenAI’s maiden developer day on November 6, where Altman announced moves to give developers more freedom to develop custom versions of ChatGPT. Paying customers will be able to make use-specific bots that can tap into external sources of information by feeding the machine up to 300 pages of prompts. But the safety-minded types weren’t keen on the idea of letting loose millions of baby ChatGPTs on corporate intranets and the open web.
If he upsets the geeks so much, why has Microsoft hired Altman?
To remove the risk that he sets up a competitor to OpenAI. The thing Microsoft wants least is to have sunk $13bn on backing the Betamax of AGI.
There’s been no suggestion yet that Altman will be restricted to one job. As well as the AI chip startup he has a nuclear fission company, an AI device developer and the Worldcoin eyeball-scanning project, so the time he can give to running Microsoft’s new AI special-ops division might be limited. But he won’t be running someone else’s AI special-ops division and that’s apparently what matters most: Microsoft shares are up a bit in Monday premarket [and now in the actual market too].
Microsoft shares at new record high
Today’s rally has pushed Microsoft’s shares to a new record high, extending their gains this year to over 55%.
They gained as much as 1.9% to hit $377.1, above last Thursday’s record high.
Reuters has the details:
The Nasdaq led gains among the main U.S. stock indexes on Monday as Microsoft climbed on news that former OpenAI head Sam Altman will join the software giant, while investors awaited more clues on when the Federal Reserve might begin cutting interest rates.
Microsoft’s shares advanced 1.4%, notching a record high after CEO Satya Nadella said Altman is set to join the company to lead a new advanced AI research team.
The information technology sub-index housing the stock was among top sectoral gainers, up 0.7%.
Other megacap stocks were mixed, with Amazon.com edging 0.7% higher, while Alphabet slipped 0.4%.
Nicholas Zieglasch, Head of Equity Research at financial services firm Killik & Co, says Microsoft has done well out of the turmoil at OpenAI.
Zieglasch explains:
“The global technology giant today announced it had hired the ex-CEO of OpenAI to lead a new advanced AI research team. It also confirmed that it is maintaining its existing relationship with OpenAI. We see the announcement as positive for Microsoft as it bolsters its internal AI capabilities while still having access to OpenAI tools.
“Earlier last week, Microsoft also announced its first in-house designed CPU and AI accelerators. These are important pieces to be able to offer fully vertically integrated cloud infrastructure, allowing maximum performance and efficiency to be extracted for relevant workloads. It will continue to offer access to NVIDIA and AMD accelerators, and recently announced a new NVIDIA based Azure supercomputer that has taken the number three rank on the global supercomputer list.
“We continue to see Microsoft as one of the key enablers of enterprise digital transformation, across the front office, back office and operational assets. Azure is the leader in enterprise cloud infrastructure in terms of offering, with more data centres than any peer and as well as the best AI infrastructure for both training and inference. Its Teams product is increasingly becoming the communications tool of choice within enterprises. It is also a global leader in cybersecurity and identity management. It is investing in generative AI as the next leg of technology disruption.
Shares in Microsoft have risen 1% at the start of New York trading, as investors digest the turmoil at OpenAI.
That recovers most of Friday’s losses, when MS’s shares slid after the surprise departure of Sam Altman from OpenAI was announced.
OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns and Altman returns
Newsflash: The staff of OpenAI are in open revolt over the shock departure of Sam Altman.
Around 500 staff have signed a letter threatening to leave unless the board resigns and reinstates Sam Altman as CEO, along with cofounder and former president Greg Brockman.
The letter says OpenAI (the firm behind ChatGPT) has pushed the field of artificial intelligence to new frontiers, but warns:
“The process through which you terminated Sam Altman and removed Greg Brockman from the board has jeopardized all of this work and undermined our mission and company.
Your conduct has made it clear you did not have the competence to oversee OpenAI.”
The letter has emerged just hours after Microsoft revealed it had hired Altman and Brockman, just after weekend negotiations to reinstate Altman under pressure from investers floundered.
In the letter, the staff say they may choose to resign and join Microsoft’s new AI division which will be run by Altman and Brockman.
They tell the board that the letter’s signaturies are “unable to work for or with people that lack competence, judgment and care for our mission and employees.”
Technology journalist Kara Swisher has posted the letter on X (formerly Twitter) – and points out that OpenAI’s chief scientist, Ilya Sutskever, has signed it, even though he is a member of the board that fired Altman.
As flagged earlier, Sutskever has posted on X today that “I deeply regret my participation in the board’s actions”.
That came shortly after OpenAI appointed Emmett Shear, the co-founder of Twitch, as interim CEO.
Altman had posted a photo yesterday of himself in the OpenAI offices, wearing a guest visitor badge for the “first and last time”, fuelling speculation he could be dramatically reappointed just a few days after being ousted.
Labour’s Reynolds: Failure to grow economy makes tax cuts harder
Richard Partington
Labour’s shadow business secretary has told corporate bosses that Rishi Sunak’s failure to grow the UK economy has made cutting taxes and increasing government spending harder to justify.
Speaking at the CBI’s “general election countdown” conference in Westminster, Jonathan Reynolds said an incoming Labour government would focus on growing the economy to help finance its spending plans, my colleague Richard Partington reports.
Reynolds was speaking after Sunak used his speech in north London this morning to argue the time was coming for tax cuts, ahead of chancellor Jeremy Hunt’s autumn statement on Wednesday.
Reynolds dodged questions at the CBI conference about whether now was the right time for tax cuts, or if Labour would be comfortable with maintaining the highest tax levels as a share of the economy in 70 years to finance its spending plans.
However, he said an incoming Labour government would focus on growing the economy.
Reynolds said:
“The focus of the government has changed. The focus we’ve got is the right set of priorities for the future of the country,” he said.
“Unless we get the economy growing more strongly than it has done since the Conservatives came to power, all of these questions about tax cuts, more spending, public services, they all get harder. And that’s why our absolute focus is on which measures will make the economy grow faster, will attract more private business investment.”
Asked about a comment Sunak made on Monday that Labour lacked political courage to cut the UK’s national debt, Reynolds quipped, “lectures in political courage from the prime minister?,” drawing laughter and applause from the crowd of business leaders.
He added:
“If you want to compare the evidence base of previous Labour governments, or the future plans we have, or what the Conservative party has delivered over the past 13 years, I think the evidence base is pretty stark.
“There has to be a level of self-awareness from the government and the statements they can make.”
Back in the turbulent world of artificial intelligence, OpenAI’s chief scientist Ilya Sutskever has said he “deeply regrets” his involvement in the shock dismissal of Sam Altman last Friday.
Sutskever has posted that he never intended to harm OpenAI, and will try to reunite the company.
I deeply regret my participation in the board’s actions. I never intended to harm OpenAI. I love everything we’ve built together and I will do everything I can to reunite the company.
— Ilya Sutskever (@ilyasut) November 20, 2023
The comments come hours after the organisation appointed Emmett Shear as interim CEO…. and Altman dramatically joined major OpenAI investor Microsoft.